Irish-Soul's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Magical Girl (Music Box)]

*Before you read this, please note that you said to leave a honest review. Thanks~

Ok, so here are my thoughts:
Holy shit, this really creeped me out! The tune was so eerie I felt very trapped! (That is a good thing) This is the kind of music that should be used in horror games. I do feel like I would have enjoyed this more if it had more sounds added to it. Like for instance, a cackle of an old man. Creeky floorboards, maybe even bubbling water, just for the affect. I also feel that in the middle of the loop, there was 2 melodies playing at the same time (however, I do understand that this is an EXTREMELY hard thing to master, and is easier said than done) All in all, 4/5 stars! (My examples wern't crucial for the sake of the song, I just feel this would be that much better with these suggestions)

ET16 responds:

Thank you for the review! I love honest reviews like this it let me know what I need to improve on in my future projects. Thank you again!

[Zenmuron Dark Rift N64 2014]

Wow!! I am one of the biggest jerks when it comes to finding bad things in audios! I can not find a single thing in here!!! Wow!!! Kudos!! Bravo! *Input word of amazement here*

Semaphore responds:

Yoco: you only compose once!

[-Thunderbolt-]

If you ask me, all songs should have 3 basic parts. The melody, the drums (or the beat), and a baseline. I felt like the melody you have would fit better being a base line. It was a great song, but you wont find people remembering the notes, because it does not catch on easy. (Now that the bitchy stuff is out of the way...) The song quality is great. The different keys you used were great, and transitions were great. The begining was not rushed and the end exited smoothly. All in all, 8/10 stars!!

Pi0run-V responds:

I am not a professional because I started making music only two months ago.
I'm glad you like it :) Thx for reviewing!

[NIMC#1: A Voiceless City]

The begining is smooth, it is not rushed nor delayed. The piano matches the setting. The drums are perfect piece. Kudos! The length of the song is not that significant, but it must have taken ages to make! The melody is hard to remember, but nonetheless it is an amazing song! (In every review I try to find a few good things and a few bad things about the song.... and I had to listen tho this 3 times to find 1 bad thing....)

HellboundDochi responds:

Thank you! I agree about the melody. I thought if it's going to be a looping song, I wouldn't want it to get too repetitive, so I opted for a shorter song and a changing melody. :)

[R4 - I want a cookie]

The song is a bit random (But that is ok :D) At 2:04 I personally do not tlike the sound, but everybody has their own prefrence. I also feel like there is no melody, and if there is one, I am unable to sense it. Although, You did blend these sounds well, and it was not overbearing. Whoever did the voice for "I want a cookie" it was crisp and clear, and it was easy to hear. The drums throughout the song was very good too. The song was great, but it didn't appear to have a melody. (Call me old fashioned) P.S. The ending was smooth, well done! I hope you don't get offended, I just want to help you :)

[R4BBIT - World ending (full)]

To start off, this is a great song. It is slow to start, but then gets very good. In my personal opionion, some of the sounds are ear- piercing. I would also like to suggest using a melody and a base line. I feel like there is only sound that may count as a "melody" (Now that I got all the bitchy stuff out of the way...) This song is very well crafted in general. I have herd songs that were too loud or to quiet, but this was perfect. Also, kudos on finding the exact drum!! I am HUGE on drums, and the drum you used fit the style, and did not take over the entire song. The length was great too. The key to all songs is to finish it before the listener gets bored, and you sir have mastered it. This is a well crafted song all together!!

[Come here, Hedwig! -WIP]

Nice job! This must have taken FOREVER to make! I'm sorry, but I don't exactally hear the Harry Potter idea/ theme (I probably look like an idiot) but I like the song! You mixed the notes very well too, and that as of itself is a challenge! Thanks for the song.

Genraltweet responds:

Haha not to be a show off or anything, but this only took a half an hour to do.
But thank you! I'm glad you like it!

[Life Underground]

Wow! You managed to blend the piano with the strings beautifully. It wasn't too long, and not too short. I took off 1 star because I think (Please note think) that it could have used some drums, such a a deep and slow paced drum. But other than that, this was an amazing piece!

LawnReality responds:

You know, I hadn't even thought about having a drum in the track! I think it would sound pretty good here, but it wouldn't necessarily be the quite same feeling I was going for with it. Either way, I'm glad you enjoyed the track! :)

[Dark Magic]

Woah. That was amazing! Like I wish I was that talented! It didn't get boring at any part! It was also not too long either! I'm glad I came upon this piece!

DanJohansen responds:

Excellent, glad you enjoyed it good sir!